In a video clip being shared on Facebook, a retired anesthesiologist who rails against mask wearing to protect against COVID-19 purports to demonstrate their ineffectiveness by blowing out the vapor from an electronic cigarette. The video carries the headline: “Doctor proves masks ‘don’t work.’”
But he doesn’t prove that at all.
The fact that he can blow vapor through a mask is not evidence that masks don’t protect against passing the coronavirus. After all, people breathe in and out with masks on.
“By that illogic, the fact that air can pass through a mask could be cited as ‘evidence’ as well,” said Dr. Amesh Adalja, senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.
Cindy Prins, a clinical associate professor of epidemiology at the University of Florida, called the video “completely misleading.”
“Fabric and surgical/procedure masks are meant to help protect against larger droplet particles that may contain COVID-19,” she said. “You have to be able to breathe through a mask, and he is just blowing out water vapor, so that is expected to be able to go through a mask.”
The video maker
The video is by Dr. Ted Noel, a former Florida anesthesiologist. Noel allowed his license to expire in 2014 after deciding to retire, the Florida Department of Health told us.
Noel’s YouTube channel has more than 19,000 subscribers and has had more than 9 million views since it was started in 2016.
In the three-minute clip, Noel blows e-cigarette vapor through a variety of masks, including a surgical-style mask and a cloth mask like those commonly worn to control the spread of COVID-19.
When we asked Noel to back his position, he argued in an email that COVID-19 is spread by aerosols, and that 90% of aerosols and viruses “go right through” cloth masks. He also argued that “basically, the only way droplets can spread COVID-19 is if an ill person happens to be quite close to an uninfected person who happens to be breathing in at the exact moment that the ill person expels the droplets.”
Noel has repeatedly railed against masks. On Jan. 31, he wrote: “Most Americans intuitively recognize that masks don’t reduce infections. But they go along with the virtue signaling to be good citizens.” In his email, he called Dr. Anthony Fauci, the nation’s leading infectious-disease expert, “a lab rat turned bureaucrat who plays a doctor on TV.”
Noel’s claims on countering the spread of the coronavirus are contradicted by public health experts.
CDC backs mask wearing
CDC guidance allows that the protection afforded by a mask depends on the type of mask and the nature of the substance in the air — whether it’s liquid droplets, gaseous vapor, or solid particles like soot or pollen.
For example, cloth masks that are used to slow the spread of COVID-19 offer little protection against the tiny particles of wildfire smoke, the CDC said when addressing wildfires and COVID-19 in the summer of 2020.
But, as Prins said, it’s the larger respiratory droplets that are the concern with COVID-19.
The primary way people get COVID-19 is exposure to respiratory droplets that carry the virus, the CDC reiterated in a research brief in October 2020. The droplets can be transmitted between people through touch or through the air, typically when people are less than 6 feet apart.
Measures such as mask wearing, social distancing and hand hygiene “appear sufficient to address transmission both through close contact and under the special circumstances favorable to potential airborne transmission,” the brief said.
“Multi-layer cloth masks block release of exhaled respiratory particles into the environment, along with the microorganisms these particles carry,” the CDC said in a November 2020 research brief. “Cloth masks not only effectively block most large droplets, but they can also block the exhalation of fine droplets and particles, also often referred to as aerosols.”
The CDC recommends that people wear masks “in public settings, at events and gatherings, and anywhere they will be around other people” to slow the spread of COVID-19, because masks provide a barrier that keeps the respiratory droplets from spreading between people.
A widely shared Facebook post that includes a video clip claims that a “doctor proves masks don’t work” by showing vapor from an electronic cigarette passing through a mask.
Experts say the fact that masks allow e-cigarette vapor to pass through provides no evidence to back the claim. They say face coverings offer protection against COVID-19 by blocking larger respiratory droplets, as well as aerosols, that can carry the virus and pass between people. The CDC and other public health experts recommend mask wearing.
We rate the claim False.